The Vancouver Birth Scenario

revised: August 2012

Barack Obama has a birth record that he is unwilling to let anyone see except his lawyer, which gives the impression that there is something to hide.  The only thing conceivable is his place of birth.  Yet his mother was only 18 years old and unlikely to have had a passport, nor the desire or finances to be globe trotting.  So how could she not give birth in Hawaii?  There is only one likely possibility.

There is testimony from Barbara Nelson who had a conversation with her friend’s father in a Hawaiian dinner club, a Dr. West, who remarked when asked if anything interesting had happened recently, either that “Stanley had a baby” or “a Stanley had a baby!”. Her name was most remarkable; -the same name as her father, to whom she wrote about the coincidence.

The correct version has to be the second one since neither of them knew who Stanley Ann Dunham was, so referring to a stranger by name is never done, but referring to a odd name is done.

The words “had a baby” is without any reference to where or when.  So, did she forget the “a” in “a Stanley”?  A nearly half-century old memory is very unreliable when it comes to the details of words spoken and she has proven to be an unreliable witness by altering her story, having first put forth the impression that Dr. West delivered the baby, which had to be dropped when the long-form birth certificate image was posted online showing a Dr. Sinclair being the named physician-obstetrician.

Worse yet for her credibility is the fact that she was one of Barack’s adoring high school teachers, having written prosaically about him, -almost like a fictional character.

There is no other testimony regarding Obama’s birth.  That is the mysteriously limited record & testimony on behalf of the one who became the President of the United States.  Even the women who gave birth in the hospital listed as Obama Jr.’s birth location never saw him or his mother during that first week of August in 1961.  No one has yet claimed to have even seen Ann Dunham pregnant, much less attended her delivery.

So mother and baby Obama were presumably in Hawaii sometime shortly after his birth, so how could she also be out of Hawaii to deliver him outside the United States?

There is only one possibility.  And it’s this:

Ann had moved four times before reaching her teens, so she had no long term roots. If she ever developed some it was after the family moved to the Seattle area where she spent all of her formative teen years, until the family moved again, to Hawaii, after her High School graduation.

She was uprooted once more from her familiar surroundings & friends and moved to where she had neither. She enrolled in college in Honolulu and attended for the fall/winter semester where she met fellow student, Barack Obama (pronounced BAIR´-eck  o-BAM’-ah) from Kenya.

Then, during the fall of 1961 she became pregnant.  In 1961, before civil rights, before women’s liberation, before political correctness, before African-American penetration of American main-stream culture, before mixed-race couples, for a white teenager just a half-year out of High School to become pregnant outside of marriage would have been a very frowned on thing.

Hence a marriage was arranged within a few months of knowing that she was pregnant.  At least that’s the assumption.  But even marriage would not have smoothed-over the cultural shock of having one’s minor white daughter pregnant with a black man’s child, especially if he was old enough to be her father, and was a major American communist figure who wrote and published a communist publication.  The Dunham’s friend, Frank Marshall Davis, an African-American communist from Chicago, was close to their daughter Ann, and even got her to pose nude for his photography avocation (selling the photos to a men’s magazine).  [CORRECTION; the photos look like her but are not her.  A fraud was committed by the producer of the “Dreams From My Real Father” video.  It was claimed that the photos were found in Frank Davis’ personal effects, and that he was a soft-porn photographer who sold pictures to the magazines, but they really came from various men’s magazines, primarily Mystique, in 1958 when she was only fourteen.]

But Davis was a very sexual person, as seen in his quasi-autobiography in which he recalls his experience of deflowering a very young white teen girl named “Ann”.  If they did have a sexual encounter, then she would likely have shed any virginal inhibitions about sex and could have easily gotten involved with another radical, -one Barack Obama, -a fellow student in a Russian (!) language class, and a most exotic one at that, being from East Africa.

People taking a Russian language course were different from all other students since no normal person would think of taking Russian.  Where in the world would you ever use it except in Russia?  And what sort of American would want to go there?

So they were classmates in a most unusual class and got to know each other, drawn to each other’s very different nature.  Probably around midnight on Halloween in 1961, after plenty of drinking at someone’s party, (Obama Sr. became an alcoholic later) they got to know each other too well.

Ann’s pregnancy in 1961 would have presented a huge problem for her reputation, as well as the social image of her parents.  At the point of her pregnancy showing, it seems that her life then followed the pattern of nearly all of the young women in America in the same situation; -they vanished from the radar.  The story is that they got married February 2, -as would have been expected in order to avoid bringing an illegitimate bastard child into a Christian society.

She dropped out of college in February, 1961 and no record of her whereabouts has been found until she appeared in Seattle in the latter half of August of ‘61 following the birth of her child.
What’s remarkable and unexplainable is the total absence of what one would expect to exist if the fairy tale told in “Dreams From My Father” were actually true.  She lived with Obama Sr. & son as a family for two years as claimed?
Ok, then where are the photos of that early family life?  But before those photos, where are the courtship period photos?  The wedding photos?  The honeymoon photos?  The love letters between bride and groom?  The marriage record?  The recollections of witnesses?

None exist, just as none would exist if there was no romance, no courtship, a “shotgun wedding”, no honeymoon, no life together.  All that exists is lots of unanswered questions.  If ever there was a man whose life should be an open book to the American people, it’s someone born to an alien father, and mentored by a card-carrying communist party member.

She never lived with the man she named as father of her child. He lived in an apartment near his college campus. His friends have no memory of a girlfriend.  A union in a vacuum, an invisible relationship, a forbidden mysteriously hidden tryst.  Fact? -or fiction?

The subject of adoption would naturally have come up.  It might have been raised by Ann herself since she was a young and adventurous, free-thinking-&-acting person.  It could be assumed that she had plans and desires for her future, and being a prisoner to the chores of motherhood at such a young age was not likely to have been viewed favorably.

With her own serious reservations, and the resistance of her parents to having and keeping any child at that point, it would be almost inevitable in 1961 to want to seriously consider adoption as the best solution. [INS records confirm they were considering adoption]

The Dunhams lived out the remainder of their years in Hawaii, with no more moves to other cities and states, and it’s reasonable to assume that in 1961 that was what they saw for themselves going forward.  With Hawaii as their permanent home, and a pregnant daughter without a man in her life, adoption was the only option.

But there would have been two problems with an adoption in Hawaii.  First is that there may have been no couple willing to adopt a Negro-fathered baby, and second is that if there were, they (the Dunhams) would have to live the rest of their lives with the possibility of encountering the adopted child that they would have wanted to be out-of-sight, -out-of-mind.  A mainland adoption would have been preferable, and possibly the only chance of finding a willing couple.

So they would have decided to fund their daughter’s desired return to Seattle where she could put the baby up for adoption through the Salvation Army.  Having been up-front with the truth about the race of the father, no potential adoptive parents were found who were interested.

She may have been disappointed and desperate that there were no takers.  That would have turned her attention to the closest big city as an alternative, and that city was Vancouver, Canada.  She may have learned that there was one or more significant benefits to giving birth there, (such as free medical care) and possibly was able to arrange an easy legal adoption in Canada.
But the adoption, for whatever reason, didn’t happen. Maybe she omitted revealing the race of the father, -having learned that that factor might lead to no takers, -leading to that same result after an eager couple saw and understood that all was not as they had expected.

Or maybe, after holding and nursing the baby, maternal instincts were awakened and she couldn’t let him go.  She may have delivered her child on August 4th, flown directly to Hawaii on August 6th, and then registered him with the Dept. of Health on August 7th by filling out an affidavit and signing it, -claiming that he was born at home.

Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s investigation found that the records in the government archive for persons on international flights into Hawaii during the first week of August 1961 are missing from the end of the reel of microfilm that once contained them.  Those are the only records known to be inexplicably missing.

Her appearance in Hawaii with the baby that she was expected to be rid of would not have been seen as a happy development.  Instead, it might have been met with serious reservations.  Such reservations could have motivated her parents to fund her return to Seattle and the shouldering of the living expenses of going to school there where she felt more at home among her own familiar surroundings, and could attend college with (or associate with) one or more of her High School friends.

The Obama-supporters will ask what proof there is that this scenario is true.  But asking that question brings into focus their failure to recognize that the same question can be asked in regard to proving that it isn’t true.  There is in fact no proof that it isn’t true, and that is what makes it a possibly accurate description of what actually happened.  The bigger question is: “Why should such uncertainly exist when it comes to the most powerful position in the world?”

But in the end, it doesn’t matter where Obama was born, what matters is to whom he was born.  A natural American is not one born in America but is one born to Americans and only Americans.

But if he was born in Vancouver, he would not have even been a U.S. citizen at all because his mother was too young to convey her citizenship to him.  And that is what he is hiding from the American people, because if they knew it, then even in their misguided understanding of presidential eligibility, they would be aware that a foreigner can’t be President.

a.r. nash  http://obama–


About arnash
“When you find yourself on the side of the majority, it’s time to pause and reflect.” - Mark Twain - Politicians and diapers - change 'em often, for the same reason. "Government is like a baby. An alimentary canal with a big appetite at one end and no sense of responsibility at the other." Ronald Reagan "Liberals claim to want to give a hearing to other views, but then are shocked and offended to discover that there are other views." William F. Buckley, Jr. “The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt.” - Bertrand Russell The people are the masters of both Congress and the courts, not to overthrow the Constitution, but to overthrow the men who pervert it. Abraham Lincoln “Good people sleep peaceably in their beds at night only because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf.” - George Orwell “Satan will use a lake of truth to hide a pint of poison”.

One Response to The Vancouver Birth Scenario

  1. Fathertime says:

    There are some records that Obama can’t change; Stanley Ann Dunham was registered in University Of Washington on Aug. 19

    It never made sense a girl giving birth in Hawaii or Kenya fly to Washington and be in classes in just 15 days.

    If it was not for the [INS records] I would question if Ann was the true mother but the INS pins the birth to Stanley.

    I have always leaned to the birth in Canada, do to another story of a High school friend report Ann didn’t know how to change a diaper on Baby Obama when she came to visit.

    I don’t believe Ann left the northwest until after fall classes were out for Christmas was the first time she flew to Hawaii, with baby.

    Obama’s grandmother files all the paper work in Hawaii after Ann was going to keep Barry to give him a BC from Hawaii. HDOH never question or ask for proof back then and Ann didn’t need to be in Hawaii if her mother was taking care of the BC for Ann.

    Also Obama’s birth in Canada makes sense why Canada has seal all records in Canada over Barry. When I read that, my first thoughts was when was Obama ever in Canada and Canada wouldn’t have any records on Obama, so what was there to seal? The Birth of Obama.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: